Takaisin

October Fed FOMC Minutes: "Found a Bunch of Reasons" for Not Raising Rates, Points to "At Least a 25-Basis-Point Hike in December"

The Federal Reserve's October minutes point to a December rate hike, unusually singling out the risk of AI investment returns falling short of expectations.

Author: Xu Chao, Wall Street CN

“Lord, make me hawkish, but not yet.”

The Federal Reserve’s October FOMC meeting minutes released conflicting signals: on one hand, they offered a variety of reasons for pausing rate hikes at the previous meeting, while on the other, they unusually strongly foreshadowed to the market that the December meeting will very likely raise rates by at least 25 basis points.

On Nov. 18, according to the Wind Trading Desk, JPMorgan described these minutes as "Lord, make me hawkish, but not yet."

The minutes were clear and unflinching in their forward guidance. "Almost all participants" agreed that further policy tightening would be appropriate over the coming months under the baseline scenario.

A "handful" of participants indicated that the December rate hike could exceed 25 basis points; JPMorgan analyst Michael Feroli speculated this might include Governor Waller and another member. Another "small group" suggested that policy might need to shift to a "more restrictive" stance, implying potentially more than two additional 25-basis-point hikes.

The minutes show that although the forward stance was clearly hawkish, the reasons cited by Fed officials for pausing at the October meeting were quite varied. Synthesizing the minutes’ wording with JPMorgan’s interpretation, the market’s current expectation of a 25-basis-point hike in December has been explicitly endorsed by the minutes.

Why No Move in October: Officials Cite Multiple Reasons

The Fed’s monetary policy meeting minutes released Wednesday for the Oct. 27–28 session showed that most participants supported keeping interest rates unchanged in October.

Many participants believed that accumulating more information would help assess the appropriate monetary policy stance and ensure inflation promptly returns to the Fed’s 2% target. However, hawkish members later questioned how much substantive new information markets would actually gather over the subsequent six weeks.

A "few" committee members argued that slowing the pace of rate hikes would give businesses and households more time to adapt, while "several" others noted that what truly matters is the overall path of the federal funds rate rather than the specific action at any single meeting.

In contrast, members advocating for a rate hike in October gave more direct reasons: inflation remains too high, and current policy restraint is still insufficient.

December Hike Path: Minutes Offer Rarely Clear Guidance

Despite the numerous reasons for pausing in October, the minutes’ forward guidance for December was exceptionally clear. Support from "almost all participants" for further tightening under the baseline scenario already constitutes a strong policy pre-signal.

Feroli noted in his report that regardless of the reasons for the pause in October, the minutes clearly point to a 25-basis-point hike in December. Some hawkish members even expressed doubt about whether enough new information would materialize after the pause, further reinforcing the necessity of action in December.

Economic and Financial Stability Risks: Underwhelming AI Returns Highlighted

Overall, the minutes aligned with expectations regarding economic outlook and committee discussions. Notably, during the financial stability risk discussion, "almost all participants" specifically highlighted a potential risk scenario: disappointing returns on AI investments could trigger market turmoil.

During the discussion on financial stability, almost all participants addressed this related risk: if returns on AI investments disappoint investors, it could trigger a cascade of problems.

Many participants explored the potential consequences should an AI-related asset price repricing occur.

Most participants pointed out that AI-related debt is growing rapidly, with a significant portion financed through complex and opaque funding structures.

A few participants noted that AI-related risk exposures are increasingly concentrated in a handful of companies.

Strangely, however, the minutes contain no record of discussion regarding changes to the FOMC meeting schedule starting in 2027. Previously, Fed Chairman Walsh announced that the Fed would adjust its meeting structure beginning in 2027: out of eight annual meetings, one would be dedicated solely to macroeconomic monetary policy strategy discussions without interest rate votes; such strategic meetings would increase to two in 2028.

Lue alkuperäinen lähteestä Techflowpost

Lisää uutisia