U.S. judge says Ethereum has ‘no terms of use,’ clears MIT brothers of $25 million fraud

A federal judge has ruled that outwitting trading bots on Ethereum is not wire fraud, throwing out the U.S. government’s first criminal case over a so-called MEV exploit that cleared two MIT-educated brothers whom prosecutors accused of making $25 million in 12 seconds.
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno a judgment of acquittal on Nov. 16 on charges of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, according to her opinion.
The ruling comes a year after a jury deadlocked and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025, and it directs the court clerk to close the case.
“It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” Clarke wrote of Ethereum.
How the trade worked
Pending Ethereum transactions sit in a public queue known as the mempool until a validator, the network participant chosen to add the next block, includes them. Trading bots monitor the queue to capture so-called maximal extractable value, or MEV, the profit available to whoever controls the sequence of transactions in a block.
The most common bot play is the sandwich. A bot spots a large pending buy, buys the token just ahead of it, lets the victim’s purchase push the price up and sells straight into it.
Most validators do not assemble their own blocks, and instead buy finished ones from specialized builders through onchain intermediaries known as relays. A relay keeps a block’s contents secret until the validator signs a promise to publish it, so the validator cannot peek at a builder’s trades and steal them.
The brothers set a trap in April 2023, according to the court’s opinion. They placed eight bait transactions meant to attract sandwich bots — programs that buy just ahead of someone else’s trade and sell immediately after it — pocketing the price difference.
When it was their own validator’s turn, a relay called Ultrasound offered it a block stuffed with the bots’ sandwich trades. The validator signed the block’s header, a kind of summary of its contents, with two crucial fields set to zero. That described a block that could never be valid. The relay did not check those fields, and it handed over the block’s contents anyway.
With the bots’ trades in hand, the brothers built a block of their own. It kept the bots’ purchases but replaced the bait with transactions that dumped the tokens the bots had just bought. By the time the bots tried to sell, the brothers had already crashed the market.
The bots lost about $25 million. The brothers’ validator was penalized about 1 ether, worth a few thousand dollars.
Two brothers baited Ethereum’s sandwich bots out of $25 million. (Shaurya Malwa/CoinDesk)
Why it wasn’t fraud
Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation, or a lie that matters to whoever is deceived.
The bait trades made no promise, Judge Clarke wrote, because “no trader who places a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched.”
She added that the government offered no evidence that a pending trade amounts to a promise to be bundled. The false signature failed because the relay never checked the fields that were falsified, so it “had no effect on the behavior of its recipient.”
Clarke wrote that the case turned on whether the conduct was wire fraud, setting aside whether it was right or moral. She cited a 2022 Second Circuit ruling that conduct that is “improper, objectionable, or even despicable” is not enough. She acknowledged the brothers hid their plans and may have frustrated the spirit of the relay software’s design.
That leaves the bot operators, who were running sandwich trades of their own when they got caught, with no criminal case behind them.
Only one wallet, holding about $3 million of the proceeds, was ever frozen, and the brothers had moved the rest out by October 2023.
Přečtěte si původní článek na CoinDesk


